Skip to content

Hiring Based Upon Credit Scores? Bad Idea.

2009 October 22
by Richard N. Landers
Previous Post:
Next Post:

In an example of technology run amok, Fistful of Talent reports on a tendency for current employers to use credit checks as part of the application process.  I think the impetus for such use is the increased ease with which one can conduct a credit check – fire up the web browser, and a few clicks and social security number entry later, a whole lot numbers get dumped in front of you.  Seems like a good value (lots of information for little effort), so why not?

Well, because it isn’t really such a good value.  Credit is only a proxy for the personality traits and other characteristics that I suspect most hiring managers are actually interested in: integrity, follow-through, ability to take responsibility, and so on.  And if that’s the case, why not assess them directly?  Personality-based integrity tests, for example, are relatively inexpensive and show no adverse impact[1] , so just use those!

Any specific piece of information about a person you are trying to get from a credit report can be gained by more direct methods.  Want to know about follow-through?  In a structured reference report/letter, ask references to describe a situation where the subject did or did not follow through well on a project.  Then, ask for more details about those events during a structured interview.  Problem solved, and you didn’t even have to ask yourself whether spending 7 years to pay off a car loan is good or bad in relation to job performance.

And let’s not forget that beast lurking in the shadows, the potential lawsuit.  Consider this final thought from FFoT:

And here’s where it really gets ugly: U.S. Representative, Steve Cohen, of Tennessee, found that many of the credit challenged were “young people, seniors, minorities, and divorced women.”  Ok, so maybe ‘young people’ and ‘divorced women’ don’t constitute a protected class . . . but you’re playing with fire in regards to ‘seniors’ and ‘minorities’.  Roll the disparate impact dice too many times and you just might come up with snake-eyes.

  1. Ones, D.S., Viswesvaran, C., & Schmidt, F.L. (1993).  Comprehensive meta-analysis of integrity test validities: Findings and implications for personnel selection and theories of job performance.  Journal of Applied Psychology, 78, 679-703. []
Previous Post:
Next Post:
No comments yet

Leave a Reply

Note: You can use basic XHTML in your comments. Your email address will never be published.

Subscribe to this comment feed via RSS

x has changed servers! The new site should be faster and more responsive than ever before. But there may be bugs! If you run into any weird site behavior, please email me at rnlanders at odu dot edu